ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Immigration Daily April 15, 2003
Previous Issues
The unmatched news resource for legal professionals. Free! Join 9000+ readers

Editor's Comments

Deport-Em-All vs. Basic Procedural Due Process

In our Editorial Comments on November 8, 2002, we wrote about INS v. Orlando Ventura, No. 02-29 (Sup. Ct. Nov. 4, 2002) thus: "This decision by the Supremes may have the unintended consequence of partially negating the DOJ's recent regulation shearing the BIA. Here's how. The DOJ's new regulation reduces the BIA to the role of a rubber-stamp tribunal in many instances. Two entire levels pre-IIRIRA have now been removed - the district court, and (largely) the BIA. Circuit Courts are accustomed to reviewing well developed matters where the administrative agency and the district court have established a firm grounding of fact, and have analyzed the legal basis thoroughly. Now, however, matters appealed to Circuit Courts may frequently be inadequately developed to the standards to which Circuit Judges are used to. The Supremes decision may now give added cause for the Circuits to remand matters before them back to the BIA for a fuller development of the record, thus partly foiling the DOJ's recent BIA regulation." Subsequently, we carried cases from the 3rd and 9th circuits remanding matters to the BIA in light of INS v. Ventura (Silva-Jacinto v. INS, No. 00-71426 (9th Cir. Mar. 11, 2003), Sene v. Ashcroft, No. 01-3278 (3rd Cir. Dec. 11, 2002)). There was also a case from the 8th circuit which directed a grant of citizenship despite INS v. Ventura (Mayo v. Ashcroft, No. 02-2368 (8th Cir. Jan. 27, 2003)). Today, we carry yet another case where the 3rd Circuit en banc remands to BIA in light of this Supremes decision.

There is a reason why we highlight this pattern surrounding Ventura. It is our opinion that there is a fundamental underlying tension here - between a desire to deport large numbers of aliens on the one hand, and the fact that this would impose an erosion of fundamental rights in America on the other hand. And we are not talking about "immigrant rights" here. We believe that fundamental rights of all Americans are to some degree intertwined with basic procedural due process given aliens. Even the barest of due process, such as still exists with the revised DOJ regulations on the BIA, still imposes sufficient administrative overhead as to make the dreams of the "deport-em-all" crowd very difficult. The dilemma for the anti-immigrationists here is this: either scrap the Bill of Rights for all Americans or learn to live with large-scale immigration. What we are seeing unfold in the aftermath of Ventura is perhaps the beginning of a backlash to the DOJ's recent BIA-shearing regulation which seeks to accelerate the government's deportation efforts. Only time will tell if we are correct in this interpretation. Immigration Daily will continue to chronicle developments in this area.


Roundtable with ECFMG and CGFNS

The March session of ILW.COM's healthcare seminar will feature a roundtable with senior representatives of the Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates (ECFMG) and the Commission on Graduates of Foreign Nursing Schools (CGFNS). The curriculum for this session includes:

  • Role of credentialling agencies in health care immigration
  • Testing and timeframes
  • Guiding applicants through the process
  • Participation guidelines for ECFMG programs
  • CGFNS: it's not just nurses anymore
Healthcare immigration is one of the bright spots in today's immigration law practice. For more info on this phone seminar series, including detailed curriculum, speaker bios, and registration information, please see:
For the fax version, please see:

Featured Article

Citizens and Patriots: Not One and the Same -- A Commentary
Christine Flowers recounts her recent experience and observations at the Immigration Office on 16th and Callowhill in Center City, Philadelphia.

Keep on top of the latest in immigration law! Attend ILW.COM seminars! You can attend ILW.COM phone seminars from the convenience of your office! For more info on the seminars currently available, please click here:

Immigration Law News

DOS Seeks Comments
The Department of State Office Of Visa Services sought public comments on Form DS-3052, Nonimmigrant V Visa Application.

Citizenship Legislation For 9/11 Immigrant Victims
Hon. Maloney (D-NY) re-introduced legislation that would grant citizenship to the spouses and children of legal immigrants who were killed on September 11, 2001. Sen. Corzine (D-NJ) said, "My legislation would bestow honorary citizenship on legal immigrants and non-immigrants who died in the disaster....Perhaps more important, the bill would offer citizenship to surviving spouses and children, subject to a background investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation."

Fallen Heroes Immigrant Spouse Fairness Act Seeks To Address Situation Of Fundamental Unfairness Under Current Immigration Law
Hon. Jones (R-NC), in introducing the Fallen Heroes Immigrant Spouse Fairness Act said, "Widows and widowers of our men and women in uniform who are in the process of applying for a green card should not have their application process terminated if they are unfortunate enough to have lost their loved one prior to reaching the 2 year threshold."

INS May Not Hide Behind State Department Letterhead, Reliance On State Department Letter With Third Hand Account Of Unexplained "Investigation" Violates Due Process
In Ezeagwuna v. Ashcroft, No. 01-3294 (3rd Cir. Apr. 14, 2003), the court amended its original opinion, pursuant to an en banc rehearing in light of the Supreme Court decision in INS v. Ventura, and remanded to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) for further proceedings. In its original opinion, Ezeagwuna v. Ashcroft, No. 01-3294 (3rd Cir. Jul. 30, 2002), the court held that a letter from the State Department which was the linchpin of the BIA's adverse decision on the credibility of Petitioner's asylum application was "multiple hearsay of the most troubling kind" and was neither reliable nor trustworthy, and expressed its concern that the INS was "attempting to use the prestige of the State Department letterhead to make its case and give credibility to the letter's contents", and that the BIA's reliance on this letter violated Petitioner's Fifth Amendment right to due process..

Certificate Of Appealability Denied
In US v. Cruz-Arellanes, No. 02-4100 (10th Cir. Apr. 9, 2003), the court said that it did not find the district court's resolution of the claims advanced by Defendant to be debatable or wrong.

DHS Spokesman Says DHS Is Dealing With Same Law, Still Doing Same Thing
The New Bedford Standard-Times reports "Despite all the name changes and the promise of an alphabet soup of acronyms, the public should barely notice the abolition of the INS and its replacement with three new agencies, a DHS spokesman in Boston said."

Commercial Database Files Used By Gov't To Verify Personal Information
The Boston Globe reports "ChoicePoint is the US immigration officer's favorite private data tool, but it's not the only one, said Thomas Durand, assistant chief inspector of the new US Bureau of Customs and Border Protection, which absorbed some of the INS functions....If ChoicePoint's data [a commercial database company] are used to block foreigners from entering the US, [Choicepoint's marketing director] Lee said he hopes immigration officials give travelers the chance to challenge the accuracy of information used to confront them."

Local Police Seek Public's Help In Tracking Down Victims Of Pastor Who Allegedly Extorted $$$ From Mexican Residents
The Bridgetown News of New Jersey reports "A pastor at a [local] city church was arrested Thursday afternoon, accused of shaking down Mexican residents on at least three occasions over the last week by posing as an immigration official, police said."

Attorney listings on ILW.COM are searched 200,000 times/year! Each attorney listed is searched an average of once each day! Just one new client will pay for the entire year's fee! Click here for more info:


Labor Certification Advertising
Do you place labor certification advertisements on behalf of your clients?
USADWEB, LLC is the premier ad agency designed with the immigration attorney's needs in mind. Our job is to make your job easier. Our knowledgeable staff has experience with all types of recruitment media including newspapers, journals, Internet, college recruitment and more. We will provide you with expert guidance on placing advertisements and the lowest costs available from any publication. We offer one stop service and accountability for the entire advertisement recruitment effort. Our job is done only when we have mailed your client's tearsheet or affidavit to you. You can leave the worrying to us. Reduction in Recruitment (RIR) Advertisements: We will help you establish a recruitment pattern that is acceptable to the Department of Labor (DOL). Simply describe your advertisement needs to us, and we will work hard to satisfy those needs. We offer a wide range of services and bring to the table expert knowledge in DOL compliant advertisement. We work with you to help assure your certifications. Have you been asked to re-advertise based on industry layoffs? With only 35 days to respond to the DOL, you need tearsheets quickly. We make these situations simple and easy for you by providing prompt, efficient service and aggressive follow-up with publications to help ensure you get what you need to complete your case in timely fashion. Regular Labor Certification (RLC) Advertisements: Labor issues are constantly changing. With layoffs prevalent in many industries, many attorneys are turning to the regular labor certification process once more. Our knowledgeable staff can assist you in reviewing SWA (SESA) advertising instructions and placing advertisements. We will proofread your advertisements and place them promptly in the next available publication as SWA instructed. Give us a chance to handle your clients' recruitment needs. We will impress you! Please visit our website at: For more information, please contact us via email at: or call us at 1-866 USADWEB (1-866 872-3932).

We carry advertisements for Help Wanted: Attorney, Help Wanted: Paralegal, Help Wanted: Other, Positions Sought, Products & Services Offered, etc.
For information on advertising in the classifieds please click here

For a listing of current immigration events please click here
For services/products of use in your law practice please click here

Letters to the Editor

Dear Editor:
I want to commend ILW.COM for recently upgrading the content of letters to the Editor and especially for publishing the comments of Martin M. Soloman and those of SJD in the April 11th issue of Immigration Daily. The points of view expressed by both Mr. Solomon and SJD provide a depth of knowledge about our immigration system, based on law and real world experience, in which anyone reading ILW.COM should be interested. I only wish SJD had revealed his or her identity and taken credit for a well written letter of interest to us all. Keep up the good work.

David D. Murray, Esq.
Newport Beach, CA

Dear Editor:
The following minutes were sent by the State Bar of Texas Committee on Laws Relating to Immigration & Nationality.

Attached are the minutes prepared by Debbie Rodriguez from a Dallas meeting held on February 28, 2003, of the State Bar of Texas immigration committee. This meeting was hosted by Vanna Slaughter and Catholic Charities. This happened to be the last day of existence of the INS which was absorbed into the Department of Homeland Security and divided into three new bureaus. We received updates about the Texas Service Center, the new Bureau of Immigration & Citizenship Services, the Department of Labor, NAFSA, ProBAR, and from the Lawyers Committee as well as from other agencies. Representatives from the Texas Office of the Attorney General briefed us on their efforts to protect consumers and combat the unauthorized practice of immigration law.

Paul Parsons, Chairman
State Bar of Texas Committee on Laws Relating to Immigration & Nationality

An Important disclaimer! The information provided on this page is not legal advice. Transmission of this information is not intended to create, and receipt by you does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. Readers must not act upon any information without first seeking advice from a qualified attorney. Send Correspondence and articles to Letters and articles may be edited and may be published and otherwise used in any medium. Opinions expressed in letters and articles do not necessarily reflect the opinion of ILW.COM.

Editorial Advisory Board
Marc Ellis, Gary Endelman

© Copyright 1999-2003 American Immigration LLC, ILW.COM